Category Archives: Competition

Waldie Griffith

A Waldie Griffith inter-province tie between Midlothian and Borders was played at Murrayfield on Thursday (2 March) afternoon.  This competition features a series of one off matches between provinces throughout Scotland, with the Province having the best shots up return gaining the trophy.  On this occasion, Midlothian was represented by teams from DAFS, Gogar, Midcalder, and Penicuik.  The Penicuik team for the day was Andrew Lambie (Skip), Dave Anderson, Jim Ramsay, and Ken Hunter.

Penicuik played a team of ladies made up with players from several clubs from the Borders. Penicuik took a single at the first end, then lost a three in the second end; the deficit was reclaimed with a two at the third end.  A close parity was maintained thereafter, and the teams were level after 6 ends.  With last stone and a free house to draw to, our opponents opted to blank the seventh end and retain last stone advantage.  In the final end, Penicuik were lying one shot before the last stone; the opposing skip tried a chap & lie but failed to keep her shooter in the house, so the game ended all square.  It was a good afternoon of sport in the excellent company of our opponents.

Regrettably, this was as good as it got for Midlothian, the other three teams all lost to give Borders a victory by 8 shots (+2 aggregate); not enough for them to be contenders for the trophy.

Second Points Competition

The Second Points Competition was played out on Wednesday 22 February, with nine members setting out to try and gain the medal.  Fastest out of the blocks in the first two disciples was Dave Anderson, but his lead was clawed back somewhat in the next two disciples.  Chap & Lie was perhaps the pivotal disciple with John Jacobs scoring a maximum eight to go into a one point overall lead.  John managed to hang on and finish on a total of 35 points (8 disciples), with Dave Anderson close behind on 33 points, and Iain Scott in third place on 30 points.

Congratulations to John, and well done to the others who all managed good scores on tricky ice.

Merchiston Team Points Match 2017

Our forces mobilised on Sunday 5 February ready to take on our adversary of old, Merchiston, in the annual Team Points Match.  Elements of our famed ‘Old Guard’ were not able to take the field and provide the benefit of their long battle experience; and one of our front line units was on overseas duty in the Americas.  The formation for the evening was Keith Morris, John Jacobs, Dave Anderson, Ronnie Hope, Iain Scott, Reg Dunbar, Ken Hunter, and Jim Cowper.

Our initial assault (striking) was highly successful, dealing our opponents a heavy blow.  Our attack continued with a decisive gain at In-wicking.  At the slower pace of Drawing and Guarding, our troops again showed their mettle with steady advances.  A counter thrust in the next disciple (Chap and Lie) saw our opponents regain some ground; perhaps tactically more of our units should have used the out-turn.  Neither side were able to make much at the Wick and Curl In, the ice was negative on the direct out-turn approach, and Raising ended in a stalemate.  Merchiston showed the quality of their play extracting a strong gain at Chipping the Winner, but it was too little too late; Penicuik took the day with a total score of 112 to 97.

As usual this was a great evening, played in the warmest atmosphere of friendship, with all participants applauding every good shot no matter who had played it.  The top scorer for Penicuik was Dave Anderson on 19, followed by Ken Hunter (17), and Ronnie Hope (16).  The top scorer for Merchiston was Avril Anderson on 15, followed by Keith Anderson and David Cunningham (both on 14).

merchiston-team-points-result-2017_001

King George Exit

After a flying start against Musselburgh in the first round, the chickens came home to roost on Friday 3rd January, when they were shot out of the sky by a strong 37 Club rink.  Penicuik failed to take advantage of the very few opportunities gifted to them by slack opposition play, and were severely punished for it. The final score of 13 – 2 slightly flattered 37 Club, but in truth on the night Penicuik’s rink of John Jacobs, Keith Morris, Roger Scott and Ronnie Hope fell short of the standard required to match the quality of the opposition clubs now entered in the King George IV.  We were sent homewards to think again!

Ronnie Hope

Midlothian Province Bonspiel 2017

The Province Bonspiel was contested throughout the day on Monday 30 January.  

Penicuik 1 v Edinburgh Ladies

Tom Alexander, Reg Dunbar, Dave Carr, and Jim Cowper took to the field in our first tie of the day at 10.00am.  An independent report indicated that the game was tightly contested with some good curling from both teams.  The final result was a 6-6 draw.

Penicuik 2 v Musselburgh

Ken Hunter, Andrew Lambie, Roger Scott, and Margaret Carr took on our second opponent of the day at 2.00pm.  Our team played well as individuals and as a unit, making life easy for the Skip.  An early lead of 5 shots after two ends got Penicuik off to a good start and we remained on the front foot throughout the remainder of the game to win 12-2.

Penicuik 3 v Edinburgh Rotary

Dave Anderson, Murray Hope, Iain Scott and John Jacobs met our third and final opponents of the day at 6.00pm.  The game ended as a peel.

Rink Championship

Penicuik met Carrington in the quarter final round of the 2016-17 RCCC Rink Championship on Saturday afternoon.  The Carrington team of Trevor Dodds, Mike Dick, Lindsay Scotland, and Katherine Dick had beaten Stray Dogs in the previous round, whilst Penicuik had a bye.  The Penicuik team was Ken Hunter, Dave Anderson, Andrew Lambie, and Iain Scott.

In the first end, Carrington managed to edge a shot stone over behind a group of short stones with their last stone, leaving Penicuik with little chance.  In the second end Penicuik responded by taking a three.  A missed strike with the last stone in the third end gave Carrington the opportunity of a two which they took to level the game at three all.  Penicuik went on to take a single in the fourth end before conceding a two in the fifth end.  The sixth end proved pivotal, Penicuik worked a good final position in a complicated end to lie two, only to then tap a Carrington stone into shot position.  The game ended with a win (8-5) for Carrington.

Afterwards, players from both teams enjoyed a refreshment together upstairs in the bar.  The Carrington team, who had played very well, received best wishes for their match in the semi-final.

Merchiston ‘1816’ Match

Penicuik CC first played Mechiston CC in 1816 and in honour of that occasion, last January, we played a commemorative match (Penicuik won).
As we all enjoyed the match it was decided to make it an annual event. So, on 13th January 2017, we met again, with Keith Anderson, David Cunningham, John Wood and Ross Angus representing Merchiston and Tom Alexander, Iain Scott, Dave Carr and Keith Morris representing Penicuik.
Penicuik got off to a good start with a two then a single. Merchiston came back with a two, but Penicuik went on to win the remaining 4 ends to win 8-2. The result was closer than it seems as on a number of ends the Penicuik winning shot only just beat Merchiston’s stone.
The game was followed by the usual post match drinks in good company.

First Points Competion 2016-17

The final club fixture before the Christmas break was the First Points, played last night (Thursday 15 Dec).  Seven members contested for the medal on ice that was somewhat challenging for a number of the disciples; despite this there were a number of fine performances.  The full ten disciplines were completed on the night, and the eventual winner was Dave Anderson (37 pts), closely followed by Iain Scott (36 pts), with Murray Hope in third position (32 pts).

Singles Competition

The Singles Competition took place on Sunday evening with a restricted field of 8 participants; Reg Dunbar came in as a late replacement for an unwell Tom Alexander.  The ice on the night was very slow and heavy, and perhaps in hindsight it would have been better to have run the stones up and down the sheet before commencing.  As a consequence the early ends of the first ties featured numerous short stones.  After the opening exchanges, Iain Scott, Ken Hunter, Dave Anderson and Keith Morris proceeded to the High Road, whilst Dave Carr, Reg Dunbar, Ronnie Hope, and Craig Brown proceeded to the Low Road (see Singles Page).

In the Low Road, Reg beat Dave and Ronnie beat Craig to reach the final.  The final itself was well contested by both players with first one taking the advantage only for the other to come back strongly.  Coming into the last end Ronnie was in a strong position being two shots up, but did not have last stone, however after three stones each he was lying two shots.  He attempted to remove a front opposition stone with his last stone but only managed to deflect it onto his first shot leaving the initiative with his opponent.  (The Gallery clearly thought it was an incorrect option).  Reg elected to strike and executed it well to remove one of Ronnie’s stones and get an inside roll for a two – all square and onto an extra end.  Ronnie’s opener was an attempted draw to the left hand side of the house which ended up just short.  Reg followed this with a draw deep into the house behind Ronnie’s first stone.  Ronnie tried to follow it it but although he had adjusted his ice he was still just short.  Reg played a guard which came to the inside of Ronnie’s two short stones. Ronnie opted to hit the front, removing his outer stone (covering Reg’s counter) and rolling his played stone into a central position for second shot.  Reg’s final draw was not deep enough to change the position, and Ronnie took the medal with a well executed hit and lie for two shots.

In the High Road, Ken beat Iain and Dave came back to beat Keith in the final end of their tie, to reach the final.  Ken stole a three in the first end of the final, and the second end was blanked.  The third ended featured draws and hits to the outer right hand side of the house and ultimately Ken stole a single to go four up.  The fourth end was draw and hit, and at the end Ken had two shots in the front on either side of the outer circle, Dave ignored these and made a fine draw to take a single.  Moving into the fifth end, Ken removed Dave’s first drawn shot, but then managed to play three ‘silent’ strikes against Dave’s further draws leaving the game all square.  The sixth end was largely draws by Dave followed by strikes from Ken; with an empty house for his last shot, Dave had no where to hide and this time Ken managed a Chap and Lie to take the medal.

Hamish Tait Trophy

This bonspiel competition was introduced eight years ago to mark the contribution made by Hamish to each of the four participating clubs.  Two rinks from Chartered Surveyors, Merchiston, Penicuik, and Watsonian, assembled on Saturday afternoon to contest the event, with each club rink playing a single end against each of the six rinks from the opposing clubs.  The winning club to be determined on aggregate score.  The line-up for Penicuik 1 was Tom Alexander, Dave Carr, Jim Cowper, and Mike Mauchline; the line-up for Penicuik 2 was Ken Hunter, Iain Scott, Reg Dunbar, and Kirsten Mauchline.

The match was played in the customary friendly but competitive fashion.  Penicuik 1 scored a total of 8 shots (+5) whilst Penicuik 2 scored 6 shots (+6), with Iain Scott skipping the last three ends.  The aggregate score by Watsonian matched Penicuik on a total of 14 shots, but their shot difference of +7 was inferior to that of Penicuik (+11), leaving Penicuik as winners of the trophy. The assembled company enjoyed a refreshment at the bar before partaking in a meal together in the dining room of Edinburgh Curling Club.

A special vote of thanks goes to Margaret Carr, Linda Hunter, Alister McDonald, and Vic Ramage who became ‘Chartered Surveyors’ for the afternoon.